Twenty Years of Patches
The water stain in the upstairs hallway had been there so long the homeowner barely noticed it anymore. A faint brown ring near the corner, painted over twice, that kept coming back every couple of years.
They'd owned the house in Westwood for almost twenty years. The roof was already on when they bought it, and since then three different contractors had been up there for small leaks: a few shingles here, a tube of caulk around the vent pipe there. Each fix held for a while.
Then came a wet October, with three or four soaking rains in two weeks. The ring came back darker, and this time the paint started to bubble. That was enough. They called us before it turned into a drywall job.
From the ladder, the roof told the whole story. The valleys were worn down to the mat. There were at least four different shades of shingle from old patch jobs. Someone had sealed the cracked vent boot with roofing cement instead of replacing it. The hallway leak traced back to the valley right above it, and the rest of the roof wasn't far behind.
They asked a fair question: couldn't we just fix the one spot? We could have. But we'd have been the fourth contractor patching the same tired roof, and we told them that straight. They decided to replace it.
We put ice and water shield in the valleys and along the eaves, synthetic underlayment everywhere else, new drip edge, new pipe boots, and GAF Timberline HDZ shingles in Charcoal. Two days start to finish, with a magnet sweep of the yard and driveway at the end.
A few weeks later a hard, all-day rain came through. That night they texted us a photo of the hallway ceiling, dry and freshly painted, with one word: "Finally."